Let
me start by saying that Mac Barnett is one of my favorite children’s authors
and Adam Rex one of my favorite children’s illustrators. And while Chloe and the Lion is a fun, clever and intelligent
children’s book, it simply does not work for a Storytime setting.
First,
the book is 48 pages long, rather than the more standard 32. That wouldn’t
necessarily make the book problematic, but the story is quite complex with lots
of starts and stops in the form of Barnett and Rex appearing throughout the
story (as clay figures), arguing over parts of the story. Most of the children
we have in Storytime are on the younger side and would not understand the
interaction of the creators; they’d only know that these scenes interrupt the
story.
Also
too many pages consist of multiple panels more appropriate to a graphic novel
format. This makes the visual elements too small for large groups. The book
contains very few opportunities (if any) for group participation. While Chloe and the Lion would make a great
story for some one-on-one situations (or even better, for independent reading),
it simply does not work for a Storytime situation.
Storytelling 2
Color Attractiveness 2
Size of Book 2
Text Size 1
Illustrations 2
Participation Potential 1
Overall Appropriateness for Storytime 1.5
Color Attractiveness 2
Size of Book 2
Text Size 1
Illustrations 2
Participation Potential 1
Overall Appropriateness for Storytime 1.5
No comments:
Post a Comment